The Tax Code Already Has a Mechanical Bull Policy: It Pays Companies to Borrow
I recently read a piece from my friends at the Tax Policy Center, “The Tax Code Already Has an AI Policy: It Pays Companies to Borrow.” I was startled to learn about this AI policy, because it mirrored another tax policy I have been closely monitoring. Mechanical bulls are taking over Idaho’s bar scene. From Boise to Soda Springs, bar owners borrowing heavily to purchase increasingly elaborate mechanical bulls, betting that Idahoan’s appetite for being thrown off a motorized farm animal will continue to grow. Some establishments are installing multiple bulls, raising concerns that the state is headed toward a mechanical bull investment bubble.
The risks extend beyond the bar owners themselves. Mechanical bulls can be dangerous. Researchers have documented thousands of injuries associated with mechanical bull riding, including serious injuries requiring emergency medical treatment. Furthermore, even aside from physical injury, the mental anguish by being bested by a mechanical beast can be devastating. An investment boom could leave Idaho with more mechanical bulls than its residents can safely ride, while exposing heavily indebted bar owners and their lenders to substantial losses.
The federal tax code is helping subsidize this risky investment. When a bar owner borrows money to purchase a mechanical bull, two provisions of the tax code can combine to create a massive tax subsidy. The government effectively encourages investments that might otherwise be unprofitable, potentially fueling excessive borrowing and an unsustainable mechanical bull boom.
Congress should consider whether taxpayers ought to be subsidizing such risky investments, especially when the federal government is already deeply in debt.
Two federal deductions can add up to a generous subsidy
The first provision is bonus depreciation. Under current law, a business that purchases qualifying equipment can immediately deduct the full cost of that equipment from its taxable income. A bar owner who purchases an eligible mechanical bull can deduct the cost in the year it is placed in service, rather than spreading the deduction over the bull’s useful life.
The second provision is the deductibility of interest. If the bar owner borrows money to purchase the mechanical bull, the interest paid on that loan is also generally deductible, subject to certain limitations.
Economists have long recognized that allowing businesses to immediately deduct the full cost of an investment, while also allowing deductions for interest on debt used to finance that investment, can produce a substantial subsidy for debt-financed investment. Under certain assumptions, the effective marginal tax rate on such investments can even be negative.
This means that some mechanical bull investments that would not be economically attractive without the tax benefits might become profitable after taxes. Rather than letting the market determine how many mechanical bulls Idaho needs, the federal government is putting its thumb on the scale.
But wait!!! Does the tax code really have a mechanical bull policy?!?!?!?
No. Unfortunately, no. The mechanical bull lobby is apparently less powerful than the church bingo lobby, and has no special provisions in the Internal Revenue code.
There is no special federal tax deduction for mechanical bulls. Congress has not decided that Idaho needs more mechanical bulls. There is no provision of the Internal Revenue Code specifically encouraging bars to install equipment that throws their customers onto padded floors. Yet.
The tax provisions described above apply to qualifying business investments throughout the American economy.
A manufacturer borrowing to purchase machinery can benefit from them. So can a farmer buying equipment, an amusement park purchasing a new ride, or a business investing in computer servers.
And yes, so can a company building an artificial intelligence data center.
That is why I found a recent Tax Policy Center article, titled “The Tax Code Already Has an AI Policy: It Pays Companies to Borrow,” so puzzling.
The article describes how the combination of bonus depreciation and interest deductibility can subsidize debt-financed investment in AI data centers. It argues that these tax provisions encourage companies to borrow excessively, potentially contributing to an AI investment bubble that could create broader economic risks.
But absolutely nothing about the tax provisions at the center of that argument is specific to AI.
The article could just as easily have been titled “The Tax Code Already Has a Mechanical Bull Policy: It Pays Companies to Borrow.” The underlying tax analysis would be essentially the same, subject to differences in the characteristics and financing of the investments.
General tax provisions are not special subsidies for AI
The language we use to describe tax policy shapes how people understand it. When an article suggests that the tax code has an AI policy, a reasonable reader unfamiliar with the tax system might conclude that Congress has enacted special tax benefits for AI companies. That the government has somehow singled out data centers for favorable treatment, perhaps as part of a deliberate effort to promote artificial intelligence.
But that is not what has happened.
Congress has adopted broadly applicable rules governing the taxation of business investment. Full expensing allows businesses to deduct qualifying capital expenditures immediately, rather than depreciating them over time. Interest deductibility recognizes the cost of borrowing, although it can also create incentives to finance investments with debt rather than equity.
There are legitimate economic debates about both provisions. Economists generally favor full expensing because it removes a tax distortion that discourages investment. Combining expensing with interest deductibility, however, can create additional incentives for debt-financed investment. Whether those incentives are desirable is a reasonable subject for debate. Further, whether the investments will pay off and whether we are in an AI data center bubble is, in my opinion, a matter that the lender and borrower will sort out between themselves, and that tax scholars are relatively underqualified to evaluate.
But that debate is about the tax treatment of investment and financing across the economy. It is not an AI-specific tax policy.
The tax code does not have a mechanical bull policy. And the provisions at issue in this debate do not constitute a special AI policy, either.
It has a tax policy governing investment and borrowing. We should debate that policy on its merits, without confusing the issue by bringing in data centers. Or mechanical bulls.
